Following up on the playlist for Secrets of a Lady I posted a while ago, here’s a playlist for Beneath a Silent Moon:
Moonight Sonata, Ludwig von Beethoven
I spent a lot of time listening to Beethoven sonatas, trying to pick Mélanie’s favorite. I resisted this piece because I was afraid it was too obvious, but I kept coming back to it. This hauntingly beautiful music somehow seems right for Mélanie. She is playing it in the drawing room during Charles and Honoria’s scene on the terrace. It was only after Beneath a Silent Moon was published that I learned, to my profound embarrassment, that this sonata wasn’t called the Moonlight Sonata until after 1817 when the book is set. I was very happy to be able to correct this in the trade reissue. After consulting with a pianist friend, I reworded the lines to have Charles thinks of it as “Mélanie’s favorite Beethoven sonata, the one that always put him in mind of moonlight shimmering against water.”
Il catalogo è questo, Don Giovanni, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart & Lorenzo da Ponte
Leporello’s aria about Don Giovanni’s legion of conquests sums up Honoria’s and Val’s attitudes toward their love affairs. Mel refers to the aria, adding that Val’s appeal was “The eternal lure of Don Juan. Women like to think he’s looking for his one true love and that they’ll be the one to tame him. And all the time all he wants is another name to add to his infernal list.” That line came out of a talk I had with my friend Penny Williamson after a performance of Don Giovanni.
A Weekend in the Country, A Little Night Music, Stephen Sondheim
I love stories where characters with tangle lives and tangled love affairs converge at country house parties, as they do in both Beneath and in A Little Night Music. This song captures the delights and plot complications of a country house party story perfectly.
Per pietà, ben mio, perdona, Così fan tutte, Mozart & da Ponte
As the puzzle pieces are swirling in his head, Charles unconsciously finds himself picking out this aria on his mother’s Broadwood grand pianoforte. In this aria, Fiordiligi resists (with increasing difficulty) the impassioned pleas of her would-be lover Ferrando, not understanding that she is caught up in a romantic game that hinges on a bet. As Mel says, Charles’s choice of music is “Perhaps more apt than you know.”
No Place Like London, Sweeney Todd, Stephen Sondheim
I’ve always loved Sweeney Todd, but it wasn’t until I was watching the recent movie, not long before the reissue of Beneath, that I realized how much this opening song where Sweeney returns to London by boat, reflects Tommy’s attitude in the prologue to Beneath.
ll core vi dono, Così fan tutte, Mozart & da Ponte
Mel recalls joining Charles at the piano in a rendition of this duet, where Dorabella succumbs to Guglielmo’s romantic games. The Merola Opera Program did Così fan tutte the summer I was working on Beneath, and the opera, with its tension between a vision of love as a game and what treating love as a game does to the emotional reality, was definitely an influence on the book.
Being Alive, Company, Stephen Sondheim
As I’ve said before, my idea for Beneath began with the scene between Charles and Mélanie at the end of the book. The inspiration was that scene was the concluding scene in Dorothy Sayers’s Busman’s Honeyroom and this concluding song from Stephen Sondheim’s Company. A song that brilliantly and poignantly sums up why people need other people. And also, I think, sums up Charles’s opening up to Mel at the end of the book.
Do you have any pieces of music to add to the Beneath playlist? I’d love to hear some suggestions. Any pieces of music that call to mind other favorite books? Writers, do you come up with playlists for your own books?
I was watching North & South last night (for the umpteenth time), so in honor of it, this week’s addition to the Fraser Correspondence is a letter Simon writes to David while visiting his family in the industrial north.
February 10, 2010 at 5:46 am
If you are a North & South fan, are you a Richard Armitage fan as well? Would he play a good Charles?
Also – there’s a slight error in “My Dear ..” of the latest letter from Simon to David
February 10, 2010 at 7:17 am
I am very much a Richard Armitage fan, Jeanne (also in Robin Hood). I’ve thought about him as Charles. At first I thought there was something a little more “hard edged” about him than my image of Charles, but thinking about it more and imagining him in some of the scenes, I think he’d make a very good Charles (one of the things I love about the casting game is that imagining different actors in the roles often lets me see different sides of my characters). What do you think?
Thanks for catching the typo in the letter! I must have been very tired when I wrote it. Can’t believe I had Simon writing to himself instead of to David! Off to correct it…
March 3, 2010 at 5:03 am
Tracy,
I ran across this Slate article on the differences between modern pianos and pianos of the past. It contains a recording of the Moonlight Sonata played on a piano from 1803.
It sounds hauntingly different from a modern piano. I thought immediately, of course, that this is how it would have sounded when Melanie played it.
http://www.slate.com/id/2245891/
March 3, 2010 at 7:23 am
How cool, Jeanne! Thanks so much for the link!